Skip to content

Why Leadership Behavior Alone Can’t Identify a Survival Pattern

Behavior or Pattern? text on navy background

When a leader works nonstop, hoards information, or can’t let go of control, most organizations respond to the behavior. They coach it, measure it in a 360-feedback review, or write it into a performance plan. The behavior is real, and it is also a poor guide to what is driving it, because the same leadership behavior can come from two entirely different kinds of survival.

I know this from comparing myself with Barbara Quan, AFC®, a financial coach I interviewed on Let’s HEAL!. At different points in our lives, we both lived in constant motion. Anyone watching us from the outside would say we share a survival pattern. They would have been wrong about both of us.


Summary

The same leadership behavior can come from a persistent survival pattern or from an acute response to one hard season. Behavior alone cannot tell you which one you are looking at.

A simple three-part test separates the two: a behavior is situational and eases when conditions change, while a pattern is consistent across contexts, protects against something emotionally or relationally threatening, and is experienced as identity.

Within one person, a pattern running in one room of life is almost certainly running in the others. The consistency lives inside the person, not across people who act alike. That is why your own behavior, observed in more than one room, is the best evidence you have.


The problem with reading leadership behavior at face value

Behavior is the part of a survival pattern that other people can see. A leader who never takes a day off, who keeps every contact to herself, or who answers every message within minutes gives the organization plenty of data. The data cannot show the reason.

When organizations treat behavior as the answer, two mistakes follow:

  • A leader in a temporary, acute season may be labeled as having a permanent problem.
  • A leader running a persistent pattern gets handed a skills fix, because the behavior looks like a training gap.

Neither mistake comes from carelessness. Both come from trying to identify a survival pattern by looking at behavior alone.


A three-part test: behavior or pattern?


Here is the test I use. It comes from three decades of watching people under pressure as a forensic investigator, and from turning the same lens on myself.


1. Does it ease when conditions change?


A behavior is situational. It shows up when conditions call for it and eases when conditions change. If the project ships, the market recovers, or the crisis passes, and the behavior eases, you were looking at a season that’s passed, not necessarily a behavior.

2. Does it show up in every room?


A pattern is consistent across contexts. It shows up in how a person runs a meeting, handles credit, takes time off, and spends money. It shows up in just about every room they walk into: conference rooms, community rooms, and their living room.

3. Does it protect against a threat, and does it feel like identity?

A pattern guards against something emotionally or relationally threatening. The person carrying it rarely sees it as a strategy. They experience it as “just who I am.”

A survival pattern that runs in one part of who you are is almost certainly running in the others.


Two stories that show the difference


Barbara’s season


Barbara worked in the mortgage industry when the housing market began to collapse. At the same time, she was going through a divorce, raising a small child on her own, and watching her income fall to nearly nothing. Her response was constant motion: work harder, find more clients, never stop. A doctor’s visit for a locked jaw ended with her listing the stressors out loud and realizing that “normal, everyday-life stress” was anything but. Her constant motion had a season attached to it.


My constant motion

I spent years proving my worth through output. As a CPA and forensic investigator, my busy season never really ended, and I layered the demands of running a ranchette on top of my office job, with eighty animals at the highest headcount. An empty afternoon felt like danger. My constant motion had no season. It followed me into every room I walked into, and I now know it as Validation Through Achievement.

Our behavior matched. Our survival patterns did not.


How to confirm a pattern: look for the same signature in more than one room


Within one person, a pattern leaves a trail. In my forensic years, I never built a case on one piece of evidence. I looked for the same signature showing up in places that had nothing to do with each other. But when connected together, they told a clear story.


A colleague who withheld contacts, credit, and lunch money


I worked alongside a colleague I call Kelvin, who would not share a client contact or credit a teammate’s work on a deal. Taken alone, that looks territorial. But he also made everyone pay their own way at lunch, even when he made the invite, and drove the same car for years. Any one of those details means very little. Together, they pointed to one question: what if there isn’t enough? That is Scarcity Hoarding, and it ran through every room he walked into.


Clients whose spending looked like opposites

Barbara sees the same question in her clients. One keeps a house falling apart rather than spend on it. Another, who had been unhoused at eighteen, spends as though there will always be more. The behavior is opposite, but the underlying fear is the same.

If you can’t see a survival pattern in one room, you’ll miss it in every room.


What this means for leadership performance in your organization

If you are responsible for how leaders perform, here are some things you can consider about whether survival patterns are running in your leader(s), or if they’re in a season that will pass:

  • Ask when the behavior started. A person in a season can usually name it.
  • Ask whether it eased when conditions changed.
  • Watch for the same signature in other parts of their work, such as credit, time off, and responses to pressure.
  • These questions and observations should never be used as a diagnosis you hand to someone. They give you information to see the leader in a different way,

A season calls for relief: resources, a realistic deadline, shared load. A pattern outlasts reorganizations and project plans, because the work was never what kept it running. That is where trauma-informed leadership begins, with curiosity about what a leader survived before the behavior became automatic.

Neither answer is a character flaw. Both are survival, and survival can change. In The HEAL Framework™, the first step is Hope: watching evidence accumulate that a small step, taken differently, can be survived.

Naming a pattern out loud, then taking one small step differently and surviving it, is the kind of evidence that over time convinces a nervous system it’s safe to stop protecting itself so hard.


Where to start if you’re the leader

Start with your own evidence. The free Leadership Impact Self-Assessment shows how strongly survival patterns show up and where they concentrate, whether inside you or on display for everyone you interact with, so you know where to start exploring your patterns. 

If you are bringing this question to your organization, or you would like to talk it through, email me directly at beth@empoweredsurvivors.com. You can learn more about my background on the About page or my Speaking page.

You, too, can heal. And when you do, you lead, live, and love better.


Frequently Asked Questions


No. The same leadership behavior can come from a persistent pattern or from an acute response to one hard season. Look at whether the behavior eases when conditions change and whether it shows up in other parts of the person’s life.


A behavior is situational. It shows up when conditions call for it and eases when they change. A survival pattern is consistent across contexts, protects against something emotionally or relationally threatening, and feels like identity, “just who I am.”


Ask when it started and whether it eases when conditions change. A phase usually has an identifiable season. A pattern tends to follow the person from role to role and from room to room.


A survival pattern is a protective strategy, and it runs wherever the person feels a similar threat. A leader who hoards credit at work may also hoard cash at home because both respond to the same fear: there will not be enough.


They describe the leader’s behavior well. They are not designed to show whether the behavior is a season or a pattern, or what the leader survived before the behavior became automatic. Trauma-informed leadership starts with that question.


Name it out loud to someone, take one small step differently, and notice that you survived it. That repeated evidence is what changes the pattern over time. The free Leadership Impact Self-Assessment is a good place to start.


Beth Jones | Leadership Performance Transformation Expert | The HEALing Mentor | Creative Visionary, Leader Rewired™

Table of Contents
    OUR BLOGS

    Recent Posts